Welcome to Cookie Kneads, your friendly Cookie Shop in Bay Shore, NY, where every treat is baked to satisfy your sweet tooth. With a 4.80-star rating from 79 reviews, we’re known for fresh flavors, warm service, and great service and quality.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Cookie Kneads
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
Hear from our valued guests
If you're looking for custom cookies that look amazing AND are absolutely delicious, look no further! Cookie Kneads made custom cookies for both my bridal shower and my wedding day and they knocked it out of the park! We had brought some general inspo for our themes and they were able to work with us to create the perfect custom cookies. Their shop is beautiful and a great place to stop for a treat and they always have tons of adorable seasonal items too!
I needed some custom cookies last minute for a baby sprinkle. I called the shop and sent what I was looking for to Kim the cookie decorator. She responded quickly with a price and spelling of my nephew’s name. I was able to pay via Venmo and I picked my order up when it was ready. The shop was beautifully decorated and I took some cookies home that were on display for my kids to enjoy. Not only were all of the cookies beautifully decorated, they were delicious! The price was very reasonable and absolutely worth it. I will be returning for future orders, and highly recommend Cookie Kneads!
I was blown away by these cookies! They are absolutely beautiful. They also tasted delicious. I only placed the order 1.5 weeks in advance and they had no issues getting it done in time. I cannot believe how talented Kim is! The price was very reasonable as well. I will definitely be ordering from them again.
We had a baby shower and Cookie Kneads made the cookies for our favors. They were delicious and looked great. We had so many compliments on them at the party. Kim was so easy to work with and made the ordering process so easy! Would 10/10 recommend.
Wow, what an incredible experience I had at Cookie Kneads! the designs are intricate, the taste is delectable, and the overall atmosphere of the bakery is so warm and inviting! I had the absolute best experience when I went to pick up my 500 custom cookies that Kim so beautifully designed based on the inspiration photos I sent her! I clearly couldn't leave the bakery empty handed! I couldn’t be more greatful for my experience at Cookie Kneads and I cannot wait to return! Thank you Kim x10000!
Second time ordering from this bakery and I have to say they are absolutely amazing. The cookies, cupcakes, and cake pops delicious. The designs were even better than I imagined. She did an amazing job!!
Cookies Kneads met all my expectations for cookies and cake pops I ordered for my sister’s Bridal Tea. They nailed the design and cookies and cake pops are delicious! Big hit with the guest. I loved supporting local small business. I would recommend them 💯 …
I ordered custom cookies for a baby shower with a nautical theme in two designs. They were so nicely done, very detailed and color coordinated in blues and white, like little pieces of art. And the cookies were delicious, not too sweet, a tasty treat that was individually wrapped for our guests to take home.
Cookie Kneads absolutely nailed it! They created the most perfect cookies for my anesthesia-themed graduation party—better than I ever imagined. The designs were spot on, super detailed, and fit the theme perfectly. Not only did they look incredible, but they tasted amazing too. I got so many compliments on them! Highly recommend for any event where you want cookies that are as delicious as they are creative.
I ordered from Cookie Kneads for my daughter’s first birthday party and Kim did not disappoint!! With only a few inspo photos she captured the theme I wanted perfectly! Kim is professional and nice to work with! Not only were the cookies absolutely beautiful, they were delicious!!!! Will definitely be using this bakery again in the future!
Common questions about Cookie Kneads
Cookie Kneads is located at 184 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States, Bay Shore, NY, United States.
You can reach Cookie Kneads by calling +1 631-328-1122.
Cookie Kneads has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 79 customer reviews.
Cookie Kneads features the following from the business: Identifies as women-owned.
Cookie Kneads features the following service options: In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, On-site services, Takeaway.
Cookie Kneads features the following offerings: Coffee.
Cookie Kneads features the following dining options: Dessert.
Cookie Kneads features the following planning: Quick visit.
Cookie Kneads features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
